Size: a a a

OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)

2019 December 16

IH

Illia Hai in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Platform
A primitive (node, way, or area) where the passengers wait:

public_transport=platform
> highway=bus_stop (This older tag is still necessary because without, the bus stop currently is not rendered on the main page, see bug report.)

"Ми не мапимо під рендер" :D
источник

СВ

Саша Войтюк in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Illia Hai
Platform
A primitive (node, way, or area) where the passengers wait:

public_transport=platform
> highway=bus_stop (This older tag is still necessary because without, the bus stop currently is not rendered on the main page, see bug report.)

"Ми не мапимо під рендер" :D
ахах)
источник

AR

Alex Riabtsev in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
mike140
Это устаревший
tag is widely used on a node
источник

m

mike140 in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Alex Riabtsev
tag is widely used on a node
Он добавляется к платформе
источник

n

ndygol in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Не треба забувати про дуже-дуже не просту схему дозволів/заборон Access. bus=yes - є її підмножиною - https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:bus%3Dyes
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Sorry for the English. I'm considering to drop pt=platform from the bus stop nodes in Belgium and only keep highway=bus_stop
источник

СВ

Саша Войтюк in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Мені ще дуже нра ось такий підхід
"It is not necessary to map both the platform and the stop position. One of the two is enough. Mappers in some countries map both (e.g., German..." (тут)
Валідатори позначають зелений маршрут без stop_position (пепервірено) і OSMAnd теж навігірує норм
источник

IH

Illia Hai in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Jo Polyglot
Sorry for the English. I'm considering to drop pt=platform from the bus stop nodes in Belgium and only keep highway=bus_stop
pt=platform is PTv2 tag
highway=bus_stop is PTv1 tag and it may be deprecated at any time.
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
It will never be deprecated
источник

n

ndygol in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
@PolyglotOSM the Ukrainian community is more inclined to the side of PTv2 schema
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
I thought so too for about 6 years, but not anymore
источник

AR

Alex Riabtsev in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Jo Polyglot
I thought so too for about 6 years, but not anymore
why?
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
A message on Carto GitHub saying repeatedly that pt=platform, bus=yes will never be rendered, if not accompanied by highway=bus_stop
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Around September they closed the ticket for the issue.
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
My reaction to that is to simply drop pt v2 and go back to something simpler.
источник

AR

Alex Riabtsev in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Jo Polyglot
A message on Carto GitHub saying repeatedly that pt=platform, bus=yes will never be rendered, if not accompanied by highway=bus_stop
that's what we are talking about - we do not map for render
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
Indeed
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
But if you don't add highway=bus_stop, it's not rendered at all, and never will be on Carto style
источник

n

ndygol in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
the matter of deprecation the PT-1 is to stop   to support it in Standard style
источник

JP

Jo Polyglot in OSM UA (OpenStreetMap Ukraine)
I don't see that happening
источник